CIP in the News: October 2024

Oct 31, 2024

News coverage from October 2024 about the Center for an Informed Public and CIP-affiliated research and researchers.

***

***

  • Cyberscoop (October 4, 2024): “Election offices are preparing for a smooth voting process — and angry voters
    Cyberscoop interviewed CIP research manager Danielle Lee Tomson as part of a story about how election officials were preparing to address misleading claims of voter fraud and election malfeasance. Cyberscoop wrote: “The Center for an Informed Public, a research institution at the University of Washington, has long opted to use the phrase “rumors” when describing many of the viral claims that can spread around elections. Danielle Lee Tomson, a research manager at the center, told CyberScoop that while there are instances where terms like “disinformation” or “misinformation” can be accurate, their usage after the 2016 election cycle may make target audiences more defensive than receptive.”

***

***

  • Reuters (October 5, 2024): “U.S. officials struggle to quash Hurricane Helene conspiracy theories
    Reuters cited comments from CIP co-founder Kate Starbird about the challenges of making sense of uncertainty during unfolding disasters: “Manipulating the sensemaking process (e.g. spreading conspiracy theories and disinformation) and politicizing the event will both make it harder to respond and recover now — and to make informed decisions about how to prepare for and mitigate the next one,” Starbird said.

***

  • Heatmap (October 9, 2024): “These hurricanes have birthed a new kind of climate denial
    CIP research manager Danielle Lee Tomson was interviewed about the potential impacts of Hurricane Helene on the 2024 U.S. election. “What’s different about this natural disaster is the timing. We’ve never had such an incredible, devastating natural disaster within weeks of a presidential election that has impacted two swing states,” North Carolina and Georgia.

***

  • NBC News (October 10, 2024): “False conspiracy theories that Hurricane Milton is part of a political plot are still spreading
    NBC News quoted a section of an October 9 CIP election rumor research post analyzing election rumors emerging from Hurricane Helene: “At the moment, as state and local election boards work quickly to communicate their plans, there is lingering uncertainty around the extent of the storm’s impacts on election processes and how they might be addressed,” the center said in its report. “It is therefore not surprising to see rumors emerging from within communities grappling with the anxiety and uncertainty of the event — or to see bad actors attempting to exploit these conditions to push strategic narratives and unfounded conspiracy theories for political gain. With Hurricane Milton expected to make landfall this week in Florida, we anticipate rumoring to continue.”

***

  • UW Daily (October 10, 2024):  “UW Center for an Informed Public presents election rumor research
    The UW Daily covered a CIP-led panel discussion on its election rumor research, organized by part of a special Democracy in Focus series from UW Provost Tricia Serio, and featured comments from CIP co-founder and director Emma S. Spiro, an Information School associate professor; CIP postdoctoral scholar Mert Can Bayar; CIP senior research scientist Rachel Moran-Prestridge, an iSchool affiliate assistant professor; and CIP graduate research assistant Zarine Kharazian, a doctoral candidate in the UW Department of Human Centered Design & Engineering. “Researchers are asking questions … that look comparatively across different platforms,” Kharazian said. “How the way that different platforms structure online communities or interactions affect how information and misinformation spread.”

***

***

***

  • Lawfare (October 11, 2024): “Lawfare Daily: Lies and rumors after Hurricanes Helene and Milton
    Lawfare senior editor Quinta Jurecic spoke with CIP co-founder Kate Starbird about why rumors spread after disasters, whether the flood of falsehoods is worse this time around, and how confusion following Hurricane Helene may set the groundwork for future conspiracy theories about the November 2024 U.S. election election.

***

***

***

  • National Public Radio (October 17, 2024): “How to avoid sharing election misinformation
    “A lot of misleading information is created intentionally to sow confusion or to create an emotional reaction. So if it’s doing that in you, it doesn’t necessarily mean that what you’ve read is wrong, but it is a good cue to sort of slow down,” CIP senior research scientist Rachel Moran-Prestridge said in an interview with NPR.

***

  • CNN (October 21, 2024): “How Republicans pushed social media companies to stop fighting election misinformation
    CIP research manager Danielle Lee Tomson said in an interview with CNN: “Our ability to look at Facebook has been curtailed with CrowdTangle being shut down, so we don’t use that as much for our discovery work,” Tomson added, but “we study ads, we study TikTok, we study Telegram, we study the alt-platforms. … Changes breed creativity, and changes also create new research questions.”

***

***

***

  • NBC News (October 25, 2024): ‘Big lie’ 2.0: How Trump’s false claims about noncitizens voting lay the groundwork to undermine the election
    CIP research manager Danielle Lee Tomson and CIP postdoctoral scholar Mert Can Bayar were interviewed for a NBC News article about non-citizen voting narratives in the 2024 U.S. election. “This is the attention economy,” said Danielle Tomson, research manager at the Center for an Informed Public. “There is a very consolidated and dedicated community of people who are interested in rumors about election fraud, about noncitizen voting, and about border insecurity.”

***

***

  • The Conversation (October 30, 2024): “Misinformation is more than just bad facts: How and why people spread rumors is key to understanding how false information travels and takes root
    CIP graduate research assistant Stephen Prochaska and CIP co-founder Kate Starbird co-authored an article for The Conversation about how “misinformation” may not be the best label for describing some of the information dynamics they study. They wrote: “Our team at the University of Washington has studied online rumors and misinformation for more than a decade. Since 2020, we have focused on rapid analysis of falsehoods about U.S. election administration, from sincere confusion about when and where to vote to intentional efforts to sow distrust in the process. Our motivations are to help quickly identify emerging rumors about election administration and analyze the dynamics of how these rumors take shape and spread online.”

***

***

  • Science (October 30, 2024): “The rumor clinic: At the Center for an Informed Public, Kate Starbird tracks falsehoods and counters them in real time
    A feature article in Science by Kai Kupferschmidt focuses on CIP co-founder Kate Starbird and the CIP’s work to study election rumors. In addition to interviews with Starbird, Kupferschmidt spoke with CIP co-founders Emma Spiro and Jevin West and CIP research manager Danielle Lee Tomson. Kupferschmidt wrote: “Starbird and her colleagues have spent more than 4 years studying the rumors that swirl around elections. It’s not purely an academic interest: As they amass data, the team writes rapid research blogs explaining to journalists, election officials, and the public what rumors are circulating and where they are coming from—and correcting the record.” The article also cites a July 2024 Science commentary co-authored by Starbird and CIP co-founder Ryan Calo, who wrote about the considerable impact political and legal attacks have had on misinformation research and academic freedom: “The real problem some politicians have with the research is that it can blunt ideological campaigns to mislead the public,” Starbird and Calo wrote. 

***

  • PolitFact (October 30, 2024) “All results won’t be known on election night. That’s normal
    PolitiFact cites Part 1 of the CIP election rumor research team’s “What to expect when we’re electing” series for an article about how election processes can create an environment for uncertainty. “This variation and complexity of vote counting contributes to confusion that bolsters rumoring and conspiracy theorizing about the integrity of the process,” the CIP wrote.

***

  • National Public Radio (October 29, 2024): “Voting officials face an ‘uphill battle’ to fight election lies
    In an interview with NPR, CIP research manager Danielle Lee Tomson discussed evidence-generation infrastructure in the 2024 U.S. election. “If you see something seemingly suspicious, and then you take a picture of it and post it online, that can be decontextualized so quickly and not take into account all of the various remedies or the fact that there’s nothing suspicious there at all,” she said.

***

***

  • Science (October 30, 2024): “A field’s dilemmas: Misinformation research has exploded. But scientists are still grappling with fundamental challenges.”
    CIP co-founders Kate Starbird and Jevin West were both interviewed for a Science feature that looks at five of the biggest challenges the misinformation research field faces as researchers look to better understand our information ecosystem. That includes defining what misinformation is. “There’s plenty of examples, where things are true, but they are completely misleading, which is a form of misinformation as well,” said West, a UW Information School associate professor.

***

***

  • National Public Radio (October 31, 2024): “Crowdsourced voting fraud claims could become grist for Republican lawsuits
    CIP co-founder Kate Starbird was interviewed by NPR for a story about the spread of unsubstantiated voter fraud claims online, which could become grist for Republican lawsuits contesting election results should President Donald Trump lose. “What we’re seeing … is a kind of motivated misinterpretation where people [who are] skeptical already … of whether elections are trustworthy — they’ve been told by some of their favorite candidates in some cases, that we can’t trust the results … if that candidate doesn’t win,” Starbird said.

Other News